Aptamil Comfort Vs Similac Total Comfort – Which one is Better?

Proper feeding is a major support of a baby’s growth during its first stage. The right type of food in the required proportion helps develop their brains and boost their immune systems against sickness or other allergic reactions.

Similarly, the wrong type of food can impair their growth. This is why there are some recommended formulas made to provide the required nutrition.

Aptamil Comfort Vs Similac Total Comfort are formulas designed to provide adequate nutrition.

Aptamil Comfort Vs Similac Total Comfort: Overview

Breast milk is the best food for newborns; it is natural, healthy, and contains all the nutrients a baby needs to grow in adequate amounts.

Breast milk helps to build up not just the baby’s physical muscles but his immune system against invading microorganisms that can cause sickness. 

And the best part is that it flows abundantly, so you don’t have to worry about the cost of buying new milk.

Experts recommend breastfeeding babies under six months, at least in the first few months of their birth to boost their growth.

However, there are circumstances where some women can not breastfeed their babies. For such reasons, scientists have dedicated time to producing formulas similar to breast milk in composition and texture.

Their aim is to provide food and the right food a baby needs. Over time, different formula brands have emerged to continue in the same line; with the increasing need to feed babies adequately, you must be sure about what brand you choose.

Choosing a baby formula can feel like a big decision requiring tons of research on which one is safe and contain the necessary ingredients and nutrients.

Notwithstanding, both formulas are widely recognized brands with many positive product reviews.

However, in terms of nutritional value between Aptamil Comfort Vs Similac Total Comfort, Similac Total Comfort milk is the best choice since it is easy to digest and is a nutritionally complete infant formula!

This article compares the formula’s features, similarities, and differences; to help you make the best choice for your little one.

Aptamil Comfort Vs Similac Total Comfort: Product Comparison

Aptamil Comfort

Aptamil Comfort is made for babies dealing with colic and constipation. It contains a smooth blend of Galacto- and Fructo-oligosaccharides (GOS/FOS), hydrolyzed protein, fat, and beta-palmitate.  

It is packed with ingredients that provide a variety of essential nutrients to sustain your baby from birth until 6months.

Babies who have digestion problems can now enjoy a meal without dealing with bloating or reflux. It can be used as an independent meal or combined with breast milk to air weaning.

See also  Enfamil Nutramigen Vs Enfamil Sensitive (2022 Review)


  • Potato starch
  • Maize starch
  • Glucose syrup
  • Lactose (gotten from milk)
  • Maltodextrin
  • galactooligosaccharides (GOS from milk)
  • Fructo-oligosaccharides
  • Whey protein hydrolysate (from milk)
  • Vegetable oils (palm oil, rapeseed oil, sunflower oil, high oleic sunflower oil, coconut oil)
  • Fish oil

Key Features

  • Suitable for colic and other related issues
  • A unique formulation that is gentle and easy to digest
  • Not ideal for very sensitive stomachs or babies who are allergic to cow milk

Nutritional Value

 Per 100g
Energy/Calories2018/ 482kjs/kcals


  • It is suitable from birth.
  • It can be used as an independent meal or a supplementary formula
  • It has a high nutritional value
  • It helps with colic and constipation


  • It isn’t vegetarian friendly
  • It is not suitable for babies with allergies
  • It doesn’t dissolve properly
  • It can be too thick
  • It is expensive

Similac Total Comfort

This product by Similac is designed to tackle the digestive problems of babies with low tolerance to other products.

It contains the same 2′-FL, an ingredient present in breast milk. It is known for its immune nourishing purpose. 

In addition to its nutritious ingredients, the non-GMO formula contains proteins broken down to soothe fussy tummies, a common problem when trying to find a formula that works best for your child. 

It is a blend of DHA, lutein, vitamin E, and other essential nutrients found in breast milk which aids in supporting eye and brain development.

Similac Total Comfort formula, however, isn’t only designed to combat fussiness and gas in babies.

It helps formula-fed babies digest more easily, preventing some of the discomforts that come from proteins not being broken down enough, as some other formulas do.


  • Whey protein hydrolysate
  • Corn maltodextrin
  • High oleic sunflower oil
  • Sucrose
  • Soy oil
  • Coconut oil
  • Calcium Citrate
  • Potassium phosphate
  • Calcium phosphate
  • M Alpina oil
  • Potassium hydroxide

Key Features

  • It is an excellent immune support
  • The 2’F-L and DHA support brain and eye development
  • It doesn’t contain palm oil
  • No artificial growth hormones.

Nutritional Value

 Per 100g
Trans fatty acid0.112g
Saturated fat6.91g
 Linolenic acid4.01g
Arachidonic acids39mg


  • Reduced crying and fussiness in babies
  • The formula is pretty easy to digest and gentle on sensitive stomachs.  
  • It promotes east calcium assimilation for stronger bones without palm oil.
  • It is suitable for the immune system
  • It supports eye and brain development
  • The prebiotics help promotes digestive health
  • It helps with gas in babies
  • It has no artificial growth hormones added
See also  Similac Pro Advance Vs Similac 360 (A Complete Buying Guide 2022)


  • It has an awful smell
  • It is pretty expensive

Read Also: Nan vs Aptamil

Aptamil Comfort Vs Similac Total Comfort


  • They can be used from birth to replace breast milk and as supplements during weaning.
  • They’re both gentle and easy to digest.
  • They’re not suitable for babies with galactosemia.
  • They’re both not from human milk.


  • Aptamil Comfort includes palm oil, while Similac Total Comfort deliberately does not include palm oil to promote stronger bones.
  • Their prices might be different.
  • Compared to Similac Total Comfort, Aptamil Comfort can be thick when mixing, which could constipate the baby.
  • Similac Total Comfort contains 2′-FL (human oligosaccharide) in breast milk. Aptamil Comfort doesn’t have 2′-FL.

Read: Similac Pro Advance Vs Similac 360


Can you switch from Aptamil Comfort to Similac Total Comfort?

Switching formulas is typical with many babies. Parents switch to different products to improve their baby’s feeding. 

However, before you switch from one brand to another, understand that there are high chances your baby will react to a new product. 

Do not hesitate to ask a pediatrician for guidance before switching. Also, change gradually to give the baby some room to adjust.

What do GMO and non-GMO mean?

The term GMO stands for Genetically Modified Organisms, which are generally not considered healthy.

Baby formulas marked as non-GMO contain no genetically modified ingredients, which are ingredients whose DNA has been altered by adding genes from something else to increase their nutritional value. You should go for non-GMO baby formula every time.

Can I store baby milk in the refrigerator?

Medical practitioners recommend not preparing milk and storing it in the fridge.

You should prepare your baby’s bottle fresh when needed and use it within two hours. Storing your bottle in the fridge makes it more susceptible to bacteria growth, which can lead to illness.

Related Posts

Final Verdict

Aptamil Comfort vs Similac Total Comfort is not necessarily a comparison that is supposed to create a rift between both brands.

This article has provided a detailed assessment of both brands to aid parents in making a decision.

As you may know, finding the right formula for your baby can be exhausting, especially since many of them are available.

Before choosing any brand, consider your baby’s health needs and the pediatrician’s recommendation. Observe how your baby reacts to a product before continuing with it.