Choosing the right formula for your little one can be a daunting task at times. It is not easy because many formulas are available in the local market.
Thankfully, this article, “Bobbie vs Hipp,” is here to narrow things down to help you decide which to go for.
This is an important subject matter that requires careful examination and analysis.
Lots of formula has a long list of ingredients; sometimes, the terminologies do not help.
Sometimes, most nursing mothers can’t handle the stress of motherhood by researching online, and they will need to rely on the information.
As a result, they may find themselves asking questions like Bobbie vs Hipp to know which one is better.
Hipp and Bobbie organic formulas are both great but differ in ways that may make one better for your baby.
Hipp is best suited for babies with sensitive stomachs, while Bobbie is 100% organic and has high-quality ingredients. Bobbie has had stock issues, so keep that in mind when choosing.
Read on as we present a more detailed explanation of this topic to help you better understand it.
Table of Contents
- Bobbie vs Hipp: Comparision
- Bobbie vs Hipp: Features, Pros, and Cons
- Bobbie vs Hipp – Similarities and Differences
- The Verdict: Bobbie Vs Hipp – Which One Is Better?
- Are There Any Good Alternative Choices?
- FAQs
- Wind Up
Bobbie vs Hipp: Comparision
Brand Reputation
Bobbie Reputation
Bobbie is a new organic formula brand in America. European regulations, with no GMOs, palm oil, or added sugar, inspire it.
It’s FDA-approved and the only American formula to comply with EU regulations. It contains essential vitamins and minerals, making it a great option for parents looking for a high-quality formula.
Hipp Reputation
Hipp has been a trusted baby formula brand in Europe for over 60 years.
Their organic formulas are free from hormones, antibiotics, and artificial preservatives, making them safe for infants with sensitive stomachs.
Hipp offers various formula types and stages, including options for newborns with allergies.
Although not FDA-approved in the US, Hipp’s quality and effectiveness are highly praised by many parents.
Nutritional Composition
Bobbie Composition
The Bobbie formulas are crafted to replicate the nutritional makeup of breast milk as accurately as feasible.
These formulas provide a well-balanced mix of proteins, carbohydrates, and fats, making them suitable for babies of any age.
Proteins
Bobbie formulas include protein from cow’s milk and whey protein, making them easily digestible for babies.
The protein levels in Bobbie formulas are meticulously balanced for growing infants, and the amino acid profile is similar to that found in breast milk.
Carbohydrates
Bobbie’s formulas include lactose, the main carbohydrate in breast milk. Lactose is crucial for giving infants energy and absorbing essential minerals like calcium.
Fats and oils
Bobbie formulas combine vegetable oils, including coconut and sunflower, which offer an ideal balance of essential fatty acids.
Additionally, the fat content of Bobbie formulas is comparable to that found in breast milk.
Hipp Composition
Hipp formulas mimic breast milk with organic ingredients for balanced nutrition at any stage of development.
Proteins
Hipp offers a great alternative to breast milk for your baby. They use whey protein with a protein ratio similar to breast milk.
Their formulas are hypoallergenic and anti-reflux, and 100% of the whey protein is hydrolyzed. This makes it easier for babies with sensitive tummies to digest.
Carbohydrates
The Hipp formulas have lactose, the main carbohydrate in breast milk. Lactose is essential for providing energy to babies and aids in the absorption of minerals like calcium.
Fats and oils
The Hipp formulas are composed of organic vegetable oils, including rapeseed, sunflower, and palm oil, that are organically cultivated to ensure a proper equilibrium of essential fatty acids.
Additionally, the fat content in Hipp formulas is similar to that of breast milk.
| Nutrient | Hipp Formula | Bobbie Formula |
| Protein | It uses organic milk protein and whey protein | It uses organic lactose as the primary carbohydrate |
| Carbohydrate | It uses organic lactose as the primary carbohydrate | It contains organic vegetable oils like palm, rapeseed, and sunflower. |
| Fats and Oil | It contains organic vegetable oils like palm, rapeseed, and sunflower. | It contains organic vegetable oils, such as soy, sunflower, and coconut |
What About Probiotics and Prebiotics?
Hipp and Bobbie have different approaches when it comes to probiotics and prebiotics.
Hipp formula contains prebiotics and dietary fibers that promote the growth of beneficial gut bacteria, specifically GOS and FOS.
These prebiotics have been proven to reduce gastrointestinal infections, diarrhea, and colic in infants.
In addition, Hipp formula also contains probiotics, such as Lactobacillus fermentum and Bifidobacterium infantis, which can further enhance gut health by adding beneficial bacteria to the digestive system.
While, Bobbie formula does not contain any prebiotics or probiotics.
Therefore, for parents looking for a formula that promotes gut health, Hipp formula may be a better choice.
However, the Bobbie formula might be more suitable for parents who do not want to include prebiotics or probiotics in their baby’s diet or would prefer to add them separately.
Cost and Availability
HiPP and Bobbie formulas are pricier than other brands but use premium organic ingredients and maintain high production standards.
HiPP formulas can be found in a few online retailers, ranging from $1.50 to $3.00 per ounce.
Bobbie formulas are sold exclusively on the company website or through a subscription, priced at $2.00 per ounce. Subscribers can save up to 10% and receive free shipping.
Bobbie vs Hipp: Features, Pros, and Cons
Bobbie Formula
The Bobbie formula is one of the newest formulas on the American market. It is said to be the only American formula that was founded and created by moms – for moms.
The manufacturing of this brand by the founders Laura and Sarah was, as a result, their quest for a better, fully organic formula that would provide the best solution for both mothers and their kids.
Bobbie Features
- It is a fully organic formula for infants from 0 to 12 months.
- Its resemblance to breast milk is very high.
- FDA-approved products modeled after European formulas
- It lacks the presence of GMOs, palm oil, or added sugar
- Its essential vitamins and minerals contents are very high
- It has a high content of DHA
Pros
- It prides itself as the only American formula that fully complies with the official EU regulations.
- The Bobbie formula is made from 100% organic ingredients
- The Bobbie formula has FDA approval, and it is widely available in the US
- New modern formula created by moms for moms
Cons
- The customer feedback is still few because it is still a new product.
- It has only one product available at the moment
- It lacks options for babies with lactose intolerance or milk allergy
- More expensive than other similar options.
Hipp Organic
Hipp Organic is a brand of formula produced by a company in Germany that is owned by a family with over 100 years of existence.
Under their brands, they offer more than 260 products that are specifically designed to provide all the essential nutrients needed for a child’s overall development.
This company originated from the necessity to provide additional nourishment for their twins in their small German bakery.
Over time, they have expanded and are now recognized as a leader in producing organic baby formula.
Their products are usually organic milk-based and gotten from grass-fed cows; in terms of European baby formula, the product is seen as one of the leading products.
All Hipp products are organic and environment friendly, and they can be used for babies from birth up to one year.
It is EU-certified and non-GMO, as well as being 100% organic. It’s packed with fatty acids and essential vitamins and minerals to help your baby be strong and healthy throughout their development.
There are five different stages to HiPP formulas:
- Pre: up to 3 months
- Stage One: birth to 12 months
- Stage Two: 2 – 6 months
- Stage Three: 10+ months
- Kindermilch: from 1 year onward
Many parents applaud this formula because it is extremely gentle on tummies that might suffer from gas, bloating, or constipation when taking other formulas.
Features
- This baby formula has been certified as organic by the European Union.
- Non-GMO modified
- It is enriched with all the necessary ingredients your baby needs, like Vitamins A, C, and D, as well as fatty acids and iron.
- Contains natural lactose
- Lacks artificial sweetener
Pros
- The products from their brands are certified organic and can be traced to their source.
- Lacks added sugar such as maltodextrin
- It lacks added coloring or flavor.
- It has no synthetically derived or genetically modified ingredients.
- It is gentle on the baby’s delicate stomach, reducing the risk of gas, constipation, and bloating.
- It is available in easy-to-use powder.
- It doesn’t contain corn syrup or carrageenan
- It has a longer shelf life.
- It has good reviews for supporting brain development with additional DHA.
- It contains Omega-3-DHA
- Free from peanut, wheat, and soy products
Cons
- It contains lactose, so it isn’t good for babies with lactose intolerance or milk protein allergy.
- It is only available online.
- Some formulas contain soy for proteins.
- Not easy to reseal, and the formula is not FDA-approved yet.
Bobbie vs Hipp – Similarities and Differences
While there may be slight differences between the two formulas, the similarities are quite significant.
Both formulas provide a safe and reliable alternative to breast milk and are designed to meet the nutritional requirements of infants.
Similarities
There are notable similarities in comparing the two formulas, Bobbie and Hipp.
Firstly, both formulas were specifically designed to cater to the nutritional needs of infants.
They aim to provide the nutrients, such as DHA, required for babies’ optimal growth and development.
Secondly, both formulas are made up of a combination of proteins, fats, and carbohydrates in proportions similar to what is found in breast milk.
This ensures that the baby’s digestive system is not overwhelmed by the formula and can easily absorb the nutrients.
Both formulas are fortified with vitamins and minerals essential for babies’ growth and development. This includes calcium, iron, and vitamin D, which are crucial for strong bones and teeth formation.
Differences
- Bobbie is a new American formula, whereas HiPP is a European brand with 100+ years of history.
- Bobbie has only one infant powder formula, while HiPP has produced numerous types and ranges of formulas, including dairy-free ones.
- Hipp contains probiotics and prebiotics, which Bobbie does not.
- Bobbie is expensive, while HiPP is quite affordable.
- Bobbie has FDA approval, while HiPP does not, making it unavailable for official sale in American stores.
- Bobbie has no palm oil, while HiPP formulas have some palm oil.
The Verdict: Bobbie Vs Hipp – Which One Is Better?
Both formulas are perfect for your baby’s holistic development because their ingredients are mostly organic, sensitive, and easy to digest, so unless your baby has some serious allergies or intolerances, they are perfect for your baby.
HiPP has a wide variety of products in the market, and their prices are quite affordable.
The only thing they lack is that the product lacks FDA approval and, as such, cannot be bought freely from the local store.
However, if you want a formula made of 100% organic and high-quality ingredients, then Bobbie might be your better option.
Bobbie product has user feedback (although it’s still very new on the market), and the manufacturing ingredients are suitable even for sensitive babies (and picky parents). It is more expensive and doesn’t have many variations.
Please note that Bobbie has experienced stock issues, which you may want to consider before choosing.
You May Also Read:
- Similac vs Bobbie
- Baby Food Brands To Avoid
- Foods That Make Breast Milk Taste Good
- Formulas That Taste Closest To Breast Milk
Are There Any Good Alternative Choices?
Other formula options are available if neither Hipp nor Bobbie fits your requirements. You can consider brands like Enfamil, Kendamil, or ByHeart.
If you want to compare Hipp with Enfamil, you can read our article on Hipp vs Enfamil.
Those who prefer to stick to Hipp’s European roots might want to try Kendamil or Holle. Our article Hipp vs Kendamil and Hipp vs Holle compares these European formulas.
If you want a more traditional approach, consider US-based brands like Similac.
FAQs
Is Bobbie formula FDA approved?
Yes, Bobbie is the first baby formula with FDA approval that complies fully with European standards.
How many ounces does a can of Bobbie make?
A can of Bobbie contains 400g (14.1 oz.) of powdered formula. With this quantity of powder, approximately 106 fluid ounces of formula can be prepared and ready to eat.
Why is the HiPP formula scarce in major stores near me?
HiPP is a European formula that has not yet received official approval in the US.
Therefore, stores based in the US are not allowed to sell any of these products. If parents want to purchase HiPP formula, they must order it from international retailers.
Is the HiPP formula good for colic?
HiPP products, particularly their HiPP Comfort formula, are marketed as an excellent solution for sensitive babies who suffer from frequent colic, constipation, and reflux.
The formula includes probiotics that can be very beneficial in addressing these common digestion issues.
Wind Up
I am sure your question on Bobbie vs Hipp has been answered, and you can make a better choice, right?
Your choice should be made on what you feel is the best for your baby, and if possible, seek the advice of your baby’s pediatrician and then follow his or her advice.